jmtb02's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Holy Mountain]

Thoughtfully executed

I don't mind that it's just an intro, I think it looks good. The textures and art palette work really well together and the music fit the mood.

I really like your work, I can't wait to see more.

-John

imjeffhip responds:

thanks dude!

[Professor Layton pt. 2]

My Goodness

I think that was just about the funniest Flash animation I have ever seen!

Perfectly done, smarter than most video game parodies, and says exactly what we've been all meaning to say about Luke's pre-pubescent voice. Perfect execution, could not give it anymore praise.

-j

Skaijo responds:

Muchly appreciated from the likes of you, bud. This was just a small project that I could finish before school started all over again. I'm a semester away from my degree. >:3

Here's me keeping my fingers crossed.

[Another Day Eight]

Fantastic.

The art style is always refreshing, and the story never lets me down. These movies are always a nice escape from the every day.

What set this one apart from the others was the choice of music, which I felt was right on track and beautiful all around. Often it seems that the musical number for any Flash piece is out of touch, but the music removes a lot of the friction normally experienced when watching Flash movies.

Thanks for another episode.

-John

The-Super-Flash-Bros responds:

You're -most- welcome
-Dim

[We're Not Gonna Take It!]

Weak Argument, Terrible Message

Wait, let me see if I have this right. You have issues with the government, so your response is to make a music-video length animation about the problems facing it without giving a clear platform or objective? This animation is the most misguided, unrealistic view of government and ways to fix it.

If you have a problem with something, do something reasonable about it.

Basically you could have done something awesome with your time. You have the talent, just a lack of direction. If you have a political stance, than god speed to you. But really, your textbook definitions and quotes from the Declaration of Independence are not going to save our media monopolies or whatever else you seemed to pace through way too quickly in the beginning... with everyone suddenly getting angry and taking over their government in a giant war for democracy.

The animation suffers far beyond your lack of focus. You subject looks like the devil, and I hate to break it to you, but portraying your protagonist as the devil doesn't really work when you want your audience to identify with the main subject. If memory serves me right, the devil is typically a negative, non-associated character. And several times the pacing was just irregular and awkward. It makes it hard to understand what you are trying to say (but overall, I had no clue what you were trying to say... besides burn and kill Capitol Hill because you hate our government policies)?

Next time, take your catchy song and do something more meaningful with yourself. I'm waiting for your nonchalant "I'LL DO WHATEVER I WANT" response from other reviews, because really, it fits your "rebellion will triumph!" attitude about things... skewed, illogical, and definitely among those who will sit in the backseat complaining with no solution or guidance.

-J

cyberen responds:

"If you have a problem with something, do something reasonable about it"

It's not very reasonable for you to complain to me about how I chose to express myself. You should do the reasonable thing and shut the hell up because this is an ANIMATION WEBSITE.

[SleepEasy]

Amazing :)

I especially liked your choice of music... amazing selections! Your sense of humor was right on, my non-Newgrounds friends even enjoyed it :). Great job, you have amazing talent.

-John

RupeeClock responds:

It's great to hear that even non-NG regulars can appreciate the movie. :D

Nice to get a review from you, jmtb02!

["Sunshine"]

Loved It

You captured the emotion of this guy perfectly. The graphical style and illustration of the entire piece was amazing. I loved the simple yet effective character, and how it was an immediate bond with the audience for his well being. Great job, you are an excellent storyteller all around.

-John

Luke-Millett responds:

This is the best review for this piece yet.

[Happy TalkLikeaPirate Day]

Aye!

Yarr! Ye be servin' upa mighty fine treasure thar. The arrrrrrrrrt was fine and yur voices were golden, yer skallywags.

-John

kinggila responds:

BlueHippo's voices were golden! :D

[TooF Leaves]

Why quit?

I am not quite sure about why the Toof series is leaving Newgrounds. Obviously, there are many more fans then there are TooF haters. Sure, you became the center of attention during the TooF Parody rampage of August, but I am still puzzled why the series is seeking a new home.

The TooF series was an incredibly original idea, something that many people never expected when they opened that Flash file for the first time. Simple tween animations fused with great character design, within a restrained environment provided a medley of quirky antics and random-ass battles and musical numbers. The voice acting was well done, the style was simple but enough to make a difference, and the setting was enough to return to episode after episode.

But the downfall of the TooF series was the fact that the author decideded to release the submissions far too close together, causing a few different problems. First, it allowed for a mass of fandom and popularity for the series to spring up to quickly. Secondly, the response to one of the TooF parodies by the author (with a comeback animation) fueled the opposition by drawing lines (even if it wasn't the author's intention, which it was not). And finally, the tiring of the series due to the amount of parodies. By the time the audience finally got to the TooF series, they were already fed up with watching several horrible renditions of the TooF storyline.

The author has decided to move the series away from Newgrounds, which I feel is only going to leave the people who enjoyed it most depressed and the people who enjoyed it least claiming victory. I think you, the author, has the responsiblity of stepping up above the cloud of a few TooF haters, and making your way towards continuing your series here on Newgrounds.

You are a popular artist. You are going to get hated on for all the right and wrong reasons. Every post you make on the forums will be judged a second or third time now. You were King of the Portal. Stamper even put your picture in his sig. Obviously, there is something more to be earned here then a few 13 year olds who have a need to band together and drive down your work.

Your series is golden. You have a great style and touch when it comes to your series, and as much as we hated seeing the portal clogged with TooF parodies, the compromise of your work being driven down because of it is now over. Hopefully you will realize the potential of what your series can offer, and instead of saying goodbye to Newgrounds, possibly bring back your series in a new light.

-jmtb02

MACception responds:

Awesome review, to which there were many good parts. But, you must see that what I am doing is the solution to one of the problems you stated. I'm taking away the mass flood of TooF animations.

I couldn't only do one TooF a month or 2, that's just not what TooF is for. SO, I'll do my weekly on the site, and then every so often put something on NG to keep it fresh.

I dunno.

[Bbq-ish Space Race]

Becoming Legend

You are definitely becoming a celebrity, and now a daily award?! Congratulations, your animation and simplistic style are all your own, I love it.

-jmtb02

Bbqbeefburgerman responds:

Yes it appears to be so. Thank you.

[BM's: Bear]

Great job BM

Underrated, of course, but I loved your character and his simple escapade on to the local road. It is a really interesting, unique character. I hope you continue your storylines in these small little increments and continue to show us where this little messed up bear is going.

-jmtb02

BritishMoose responds:

I'd never intended to continue this project, but after a review like that, I must say, it seems like a good idea. Perhaps a longer episode comprised of short "chapters", similar to the one cartoon posted here?
Thanks very much for the review!